Evaluate Pension Payout Options

Take the lump sum or the monthly pension? See the trade-off.

Your numbers

$
$
%

Comparison

Lump sum grows to
,
Compares investing the lump sum against the total pension payments over the years you expect to collect. It ignores taxes, survivor benefits, and the security of a guaranteed check, which have real value. Illustrative.
About this calculator

Evaluate Pension Payout Options

A pension payout calculator compares taking a lump sum with the lifetime monthly pension, helping you weigh investing the lump against the security of a guaranteed check.

Lump sum vs. monthly

Many pensions offer a choice: a one-time lump sum or a monthly payment for life. The lump sum gives you control and can be invested or left to heirs, but you bear the investment and longevity risk. The monthly pension is guaranteed income you can't outlive, but usually stops at death (or is reduced for a survivor) and may not adjust for inflation.

How to compare

One useful lens is the pension's payout rate, annual pension divided by the lump sum. If it's high relative to what you could safely earn investing, the pension is attractive; if low, the lump sum may win. But the guaranteed check has real value against market and longevity risk. Consider taxes, your health, survivor needs, and other income, this is illustrative, not advice.

How to use it

  1. Enter the lump-sum offer and monthly pension.
  2. Enter the return if you invest the lump.
  3. Set the years you expect to draw.
  4. Compare the two options.

Frequently asked questions

Should I take a pension lump sum or monthly payments?

It depends on the payout rate, your health and longevity, other income, and comfort with investing. The monthly check offers guaranteed, longevity-proof income.

What is the pension payout rate?

Annual pension divided by the lump sum. A high rate favors the pension; a low rate may favor investing the lump sum yourself.

What does the guaranteed pension protect against?

Market risk and longevity risk, you can't outlive it. That security has real value the raw numbers don't fully capture.

See the exact formula and a worked example on our methodology page.

Related calculators